Monday , June 24 2019
Home / Latest News / Victoria needs to build a path to transparency

Victoria needs to build a path to transparency

The most recent Transurban deal, for example, the $6.7 billion West Gate Tunnel, was the company’s idea. There was no tender. The government has bypassed some basic governance principles – transparency, accountability, effectiveness and due diligence. Taxpayers have not been able to scrutinise and assess costs (direct and opportunity) and benefits. Transurban is but one of a number of construction consortiums, consultants, planners and accountants upon which governments of both hues have showered money.


An army of beneficiaries is given a detailed look at the numbers, though, as our investigation highlights. Outsourcing so much to a limited pool of professionals creates potential for conflicts of interest – there is no strong incentive to lower costs or estimates – and is partly responsible for the alarming cost blowouts revealed in our coverage.

The escalating cost of infrastructure-site wages and allowances is also cause for alarm – the unions defend the wages as reasonable recompense for dangerous work, but there is no compelling case for a cost disparity that leaves Sydney construction crews 28 per cent less expensive than those in Melbourne.

North East Link, which Mr Andrews said in 2016 would cost $10 billion, is a stark example of cost blowout; widening the Eastern Freeway and other extras expanded that to $15.8 billion. Opportunity cost: the gap would be sufficient to construct five new Royal Children’s Hospitals.

We acknowledge that work has begun on the new Footscray Hospital, and that there is a big school-building program. But we need to know if the prices we’re paying for roads and rail are real value or are inflated by the factors that have given us such a super-heated infrastructure boom.

Mr Andrews deserved support for getting on with a long-overdue infrastructure drive. But he needs to allow real scrutiny of his big spending, and transparency for the taxpayers footing the bill.

About admin

Check Also

Bernie Sanders announces plan to cancel US student debt

Washington: Days before the first Democratic presidential debates, Senator Bernie Sanders and House progressives came …