But Hocking was told definitively that based on form those umpires deserved to be picked, while Shane McInerny, Dean Margetts and Jeff Dalgleish – who have more than 1000 games of experience between them – were all left out.
The selections saw several clubs involved in finals question whether the league was trying to promote youth within umpiring ranks, but that’s been strongly denied by Hocking, who has admitted to asking the question of the umpiring group.
Adding to the intrigue surrounding the situation, only one of the five debutants have survived for the two games this week, with the AFL picking a much more experienced batch for the two semi-finals.
Two umpires were officiating their first final in West Coast’s demolition of Essendon, with veteran Matt Stevic watching over first timers Leigh Fisher and Andrew Stephens.
Nick Foot (just over 100 games) and Nathan Williamson (just over 50) joined the experienced Shaun Ryan for the physical encounter between Greater Western and the Western Bulldogs, while the AFL gave Craig Fleer the opportunity to umpire his first final at the Gabba between Brisbane and Richmond, alongside senior teammates Matthew Nicholls and Chris Donlon.
Stephens has been handed his second final for Friday night’s clash between Geelong and West Coast, alongside Simon Meredith and Nicholls.Three of the most experienced umpires in the game will handle Brisbane’s showdown with the Giants in Stevic, Ryan and Ray Chamberlain.
It means, for a second week in a row, that Margetts, McInerny and Dalgleish miss out based on form.
Two-hundred gamer Rob Findlay and the highly respected Brendan Hosking have also been overlooked.
The omissions have come as a surprise to those at club land, particularly when you consider that 400 gamer Brett Rosebury is unavailable due to injury.