Sunday , July 12 2020
Home / Federal Politics / There was never a need for Labor’s medevac law

There was never a need for Labor’s medevac law


Under a Coalition government the boats have stopped and there are no longer children in detention. There has been a thorough, thoughtful and concerted effort across many government portfolios and jurisdictions, including working with our closest neighbours to clamp down on illegal and highly dangerous people smuggling.

As the calm was returning to our shores, just over a year ago the opposition attempted to wedge the government in the lead-up to an election it thought it would win by supporting the passage of the medevac legislation. This legislation changed the ultimate responsibility regarding medical transfers for those in offshore processing centres from the government to doctors.

Prior to the introduction of the medevac legislation, medical advice informed the government’s decision to bring those on Manus and Nauru to Australia on medical transfer – not the other way around. With the repeal of medevac we now return to a system where the ultimate decision remains in the hands of the government.

This reflects a situation analogous to a decision being made about the optimal response to a medical emergency on a plane flight from Australia to London. If a passenger develops chest pain in the air it is the pilot who decides whether the plane turns back – not the doctor. The doctor’s responsibility is to the individual passenger. The pilot’s is to everyone on board.

So too for the government, which is responsible for making decisions regarding medical transfer on a regular basis that take many conflicting and vested interests into account and then make a decision that is fair and reasonable on behalf of the Australian taxpayer whom it serves.

Prior to medevac, the government’s medical transfer provisions had brought over 900 people from Manus and Nauru to Australia to receive medical attention. There was never a need for Labor’s medevac law.


At the conclusion of the 12 months that medevac was in effect, 184 individuals had been transferred to Australia from either Manus or Nauru. As of December 2, 2019, none of them were in a hospital and five individuals had refused treatment on arrival. A further 49 individuals had refused an induction chest X-ray or pathology on arrival.

Those against the repeal of medevac tried to stir up an emotional campaign that left the public, both in Australia and internationally, with the misunderstanding that those in offshore processing centres were simply left to their own devices without the support and medical attention they needed. This couldn’t be further from the truth. At the start of December 2019, on Nauru there were 51 contracted health professionals and 22 mental health professionals providing services to 258 transitory persons. In PNG there are 32 contracted health professionals and 24 mental health professionals for 208 transitory persons.

In addition, the Australian government continues to work with the governments of Nauru and PNG to ensure there is a full range of health services, including welfare and mental health support services. By placing the decision-making firmly in the hands of the government, and the Australian government in turn providing adequate medical support, the balance is restored to ensuring appropriate medical transfers in the context of border integrity decisions.

For a country with a large border that is geographically difficult to defend, the Coalition has created a system that ensures a balanced and fair approach to those who need our support.

Dr Katie Allen MP is the federal member for Higgins. She was formerly a doctor and research professor.

Most Viewed in Politics


About admin

Check Also

Domestic violence on the rise during pandemic

One in three women who experienced domestic violence or coercive control said that, on at …