“This information simply shows the total number of subscribers in various areas at points in time,” Mr Lloyd said. “This information can help show trends in population movements immediately before and after the lockdown measures with the aim of assisting in the reduction of the spread of COVID-19.”
When asked by a journalist a week ago whether he would follow the British government, which is using such data from telcos to track whether Britons are following lockdown laws, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said: “the Australian government isn’t doing that.”
“What I want to be clear about is the policies and measures that we will put in place for Australia will be right for Australia,” Mr Morrison said last Sunday.
“They’ll understand how Australia works and how Australia thinks and what our rules are and what our society understands and accepts. Our values. That’s what we will do in Australia.“
Vodafone did not request nor receive any payment for providing the information to government, Mr Lloyd said, adding that “no personal information has been provided, and no personal information could be derived from it”. Last year, Vodafone said it had six million mobile subscribers in Australia.
The Prime Minister’s office directed the Sun-Herald and Sunday Age to the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, which confirmed via a departmental spokesperson that “a telecommunications provider in Australia offered PM&C aggregated, anonymised data showing how busy cities like Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane are currently compared with this time last year”.
“This data can provide a picture of the effectiveness of measures taken to address the COVID-19 crisis generally,” the spokesperson said, adding that “no personal information has been provided to PM&C by any telecommunications company nor was it requested”.
A government source said Vodafone approached the PM’s department first to offer the data. Telstra and Optus did not say whether they also provided location data to authorities.
NSW Customer Service Minister Victor Dominello said the NSW government’s number one priority was community safety and saving lives. “Privacy and the rights of our citizens are paramount, we cannot and do not try to determine individual movement. Any data we use is anonymised and subject to rigorous privacy and security settings,” Mr Dominello said.
“The more we can measure and model this virus, the better we can respond to it and the more lives we can save.”
But Mr Dominello said NSW would “absolutely not” consider using telco data to enforce isolation of people by checking whether they leave their premises.
The terms “anonymised” and “aggregated” mean the data is displayed in a summary form for purposes such as statistical analysis. In theory, this means individuals cannot be identified in it. The ability for individuals to be tracked using mobile location data is possible but with legal hurdles.
A Telstra spokesperson said: “There’s a careful balance to be maintained between ensuring law enforcement and the government has the information they need to protect the country and for people to be confident their data and privacy is being handled with respect and due consideration.
“We work closely with intelligence agencies and law enforcement to support national security and safety efforts under the relevant legislation. Any data requests from law enforcement or government are confidential so we’re unable to disclose if we’ve had any requests.”
Optus said its priority was to keep Australians connected and safe. “This includes working with our Commonwealth and state governments to assist their efforts in navigating our country through these challenging times. We do not publicly share the requests we receive.”
NSW Health said it had not requested data from telcos to track an individual’s movements but that it was investigating the use of a range of technologies to enhance its contact tracing process, whereby it identifies those who need to self-isolate after coming into contact with a coronavirus carrier.
In the early days of the outbreak in February, South Australia’s health department used an Apple iPhone’s inbuilt location services in a bid to trace the historical movements of a couple diagnosed with coronavirus. “The use of phone data was a very unique situation,” an SA Health spokeswoman said. “The couple involved didn’t speak much English and were unfamiliar with Adelaide so weren’t able to clearly recount where they had been to contact tracers.”
The couple volunteered their phones to South Australia Police, who worked with SA’s Chief Public Health Officer to analyse the data.
Ben Grubb is a Desk Editor/Locum Homepage Editor for The Sydney Morning Herald.