Monday , September 21 2020
Breaking News
Home / Business / High Court and Dyson Heydon have failed women

High Court and Dyson Heydon have failed women

Yet the crucial difference here is that this involves the High Court of Australia, the most solemn and powerful court in the land. The Age agrees with Justice Kiefel, it is a national embarrassment that a senior figure of the court has been found to have sexually harassed women. Like a church or a school, this should be the safest of workplaces. The court’s judgments are literally the last word in disputes on everything from freedom of speech to sexual crimes.


If the High Court expects its judgments on these matters to be respected, its members must be beyond reproach. The Abbott government handpicked Mr Heydon to run its royal commission into trade unions based on his reputation for integrity.

Mr Heydon has said through a lawyer that he denies the allegations and if he caused offence it was ‘‘inadvertent and unintentional’’. He said the review was not a court of law and not conducted using normal court procedure. He noted in his response to The Age’s story that he was not permitted to cross-examine his accusers. Yet, given the High Court’s formidable expertise in adjudicating procedural fairness, it seems highly unlikely that Mr Heydon was not given the chance to respond or that the claims about his conduct were not subject to rigorous scrutiny.

While Mr Heydon bears personal responsibility for his actions, the High Court as an organisation has failed here, too. Justice Kiefel has promised to review the court’s policies relating to sexual harassment, especially involving the induction of associates. It is disappointing that a body which sits in judgment on others has failed to implement 21st-century management techniques.

It is also dispiriting that it has taken so long for the truth about Mr Heydon’s behaviour to come out. But there is a positive message. While the odds are all too often stacked against women, the story shows they can speak out against the niggling sleaze that still confronts them in the workplace. With determination, they can change even the loftiest and most immovable of institutions.

Get our Morning & Evening Edition newsletters

The most important news, analysis and insights delivered to your inbox at the start and end of each day. Sign up here.

About admin

Check Also

The Short Squeeze: The waiting game

The latest episode of the Short Squeeze is now available. This week Lucy Battersby is …