Friday , October 30 2020
Breaking News
Home / Latest News / Sorrento hotelier files High Court challenge to Melbourne’s lockdown

Sorrento hotelier files High Court challenge to Melbourne’s lockdown


The High Court writ says that the lockdown orders made under the Public Health and Wellbeing Act are unconstitutional, inappropriate and inconsistent with a system of representative and responsible government.

“[The lockdown orders] have no legitimate purpose that is compatible with … the system of representative and responsible government,” the writ alleges.

“[The lockdown orders] are not reasonably appropriate and adapted to serve any legitimate purpose in a manner that is compatible with … the system of representative and responsible government.”

Mr Gerner is seeking a declaration that sections of the Public Health and Wellbeing Act and the lockdown directions are invalid due to their unconstitutionality, plus costs associated with the litigation.

On Sunday, Premier Daniel Andrews extended Victoria’s state of disaster for another four weeks and conceded it was highly unlikely Melbourne would see a major easing in restrictions, such as the anticipated reopening of retail businesses, from October 19.

Mr Walker, a Sydney-based barrister, was most recently appointed to a special commission of inquiry to investigate how the Ruby Princess cruise liner came to dock in Australia and spread COVID-19 to NSW.

Attorneys-general from states and territories throughout Australia have also been invited to make submissions.

The High Court writ follows several other challenges making their way through Victoria’s courts, including the curfew challenge in Victoria’s Supreme Court and at least three class actions filed in relation to the botched hotel quarantine scheme.


In a statement provided to The Age on Sunday, Mr Gerner said: “I am the plaintiff and reside on the Mornington Peninsula where I own a restaurant and bar located in Sorrento”.

“The Victorian government has engaged in an unnecessary lockdown of the state and the economy, denying our basic freedoms as Australian citizens under our federal constitution, including our right to freedom of movement,” Mr Gerner said.

“We will apply to the court for a declaration confirming these freedoms and to set aside the disproportionate and unreasonable responses imposed by the Victorian government.”

The High Court has recently finalised their listings for October and November and may have to sit on additional days or suspend other hearings if a judge deems the case of sufficient importance to hear urgently.

The matter has not yet been listed for an initial hearing.

Sign up to our Coronavirus Update newsletter

Get our Coronavirus Update newsletter for the day’s crucial developments at a glance, the numbers you need to know and what our readers are saying. Sign up to The Sydney Morning Herald’s newsletter here and The Age’s here.

Most Viewed in National


About admin

Check Also

Coronavirus updates LIVE: WA border to reopen as Victoria records four new COVID-19 cases; Qld border to stay closed to Greater Sydney as Australian death toll stands at 907

The White House coronavirus task force is singing a very different tune from the president, …