The building, made of weatherboard with a hardwood floor and corrugated iron roof, is not heritage listed, although a permit would be needed from the Maribyrnong City Council to undertake works, which could include demolition.
Footscray Historical Society secretary Steve Wilson said the group opposed the hall’s demolition.
“Keeping the building intact preserves the social history of the local area,” he said.
Tate Moore, from auctioneers Jas Stephens Real Estate, said the place was hard to value, because there was no precedent.
He hasn’t previously handled a pigeon clubhouse sale “and probably never will again”.
Mr Moore said some prospective buyers were interested in incorporating the existing hall into a residence; others were not.
He said the 195 square metres of land was a good size for a single-fronted home, offered rear access into Brooks Place and was close to the train station, schools and Yarraville and Seddon shops.
The sale will break Mr Saggers’ 75-year family link to the site.
His father Max and uncle Les joined the club in the mid-1940s after army service.
As a child in the early 1960s, John remembers regular pigeon shows in the hall and talks on how to prepare pigeons for races.
There were mysterious smoke nights. “I don’t know what that entailed,” Mr Saggers said. “I was always too young and never allowed to go.”
A personal highlight was in 1998 when his pigeon, Toey, beat 1500 other western suburbs birds released in north-western New South Wales, to be first home over 600 miles (965 kilometres) and 14 hours.
At the hall, he slotted the bird’s leg ring in to the pigeon time stamping clock. There was no wild party but “it was an adrenalin rush”, Mr Saggers said.
The club held barbecues where members teased each other about football, not pigeons.
“No one ever knocked anyone for coming last in pigeons. In pigeon racing you can run first one week and last the next.”
Today, the club has eight members and can no longer afford the hall’s rates and insurance.
Yarraville members will continue to meet at the Western Pigeon Federation in Sunshine.
Proceeds of the Yarraville hall sale will go into a trust for future projects such as buying equipment and advertising to recruit new members.
Carolyn Webb is a reporter for The Age.