Victorian leader of the Nationals Peter Walsh, whose electorate of Murray Plains takes in Swan Hill, said his office had been fielding calls since Friday afternoon from residents wondering the same thing.
“The [statewide lockdown] is not proportionate to the issue at all and it severely disadvantages communities that are three, four, five hundred kilometres away from a case in Melbourne,” Mr Walsh said.
Mr Walsh said the latest lockdown would be the last straw for some businesses who had already weathered border closures, travel restrictions and full-scale lockdowns despite their communities having never recorded a case.
“I don’t think [the Andrews government] have any confidence in their ability to manage contact tracing,” he said.
Independent state Member for Mildura Ali Cupper said the blanket restrictions would be difficult for regional people to accept.
“The Stage four restrictions come as a shock and I know and feel the frustration in our community given we are so far removed from Melbourne where the current outbreak is,” she said.
“The level of severity of these restrictions is something we have not experienced before and it will turn people’s lives upside down.
While it was guaranteed to be “pretty tough few days”, Mr Cupper said the Andrews Government needed to evaluate the outbreak’s spread and outline a more nuanced city-country approach by Wednesday.
She suggested grading different regions of the state according to their individual risk. A better grading would mean lighter restrictions and vice versa.
Australian Hotels Association president David Canny said he was concerned about the mental welfare of regional Victorian venue operators.
“We understand there’s a risk but the response has got to be proportionate to that risk,” he said.
“Again we look at NSW, they have risk and they shut down suburbs and try to keep business going where they can. This again hasn’t happened. It’s like it’s the easy way – just do it everywhere. How do we explain to the guys in Horsham, Echuca, Mildura: ‘Sorry, you’re included in this’.”
Regional communities were able to return to a semblance of normal life during the 2020 months-long lockdown because of the police and army “ring of steel” around Melbourne that buffered the virus-free country from the infected suburbs.
Premier Daniel Andrews said on Saturday it was not possible to roll out a comprehensive ring of steel in short time.
“If you have soft rules in the country and you have a much harder lockdown in a city – and you haven’t got time because it’s a short, sharp lockdown to get a comprehensive ring of steel up – people from Melbourne will go to the regions [and] they could potentially take the virus with them,” he said.
“I know that it’s a bit counterintuitive, [and] people say ‘well, we’re a long way from Melbourne and there are no cases’. Yes, that’s how we want it to stay.”
Chief executive of Murray Regional Tourism Mark Francis said the border communities had the added complication of NSW government hotspot directives, which were still being changed late into Friday night.
He called on authorities from both sides of the river to run scenario planning that could be rolled out – and understood by everyone – the moment any hotspots or lockdowns were declared.
Another problem was the “time lag” between press conference and on-the-ground clarification, he said. One example involved accommodation providers who were told to shut down unless they had unspecified “other reasons” to stay open.
“Those reasons are clearer now,” Mr Francis said. “If you had people already in you could keep housing them. If you needed to open for essential workers you could do that too. But none of that was clear.”
Zach is a reporter at The Age. Got a story? Email me at email@example.com