Mayne might not come up for the GWS game after copping a heavy knock. Should he come out, his position must be filled by a kid.
It is clear from a perusal of Collingwood’s playing stocks and of the largely injury-free teams they’ve fielded (a rarity in Buckley’s time) this season that they are well short of premiership class; at their best, the Pies might snatch a lower berth in the top eight, but, in the short term, they’ve been weakened by the trading fire sale in which Adam Treloar, Jaidyn Stephenson and Tom Phillips were brutally offloaded.
Forced into the fire sale by long-term salary cap mismanagement (and the deferral of payments when they were trying to win a flag), last December brought a badly needed youth infusion via the draft, as Ollie Henry, Fin Macrae, Reef McInnes, Caleb Poulter, Liam McMahon and McCreery were drafted.
The best-case scenario for the Pies would be to emulate what Port Adelaide have achieved since their super draft of 2018: bring in a raft of talented kids to support a strong seasoned core, thereby lifting a mid-table team back into a potential premiership window.
Regardless of whether this is possible, Collingwood sorely needed a draft hand; if they did not replenish, they would have found themselves in a painful rebuild within a few years as Scott Pendlebury, Steele Sidebottom and Jeremy Howe shuffle off.
Their round 2 and round 3 teams ranked fourth for age (26.5 years) and fifth for average games – not the ideal profile in a middle-order team.
This year’s priority, thus, must be to position the club for another tilt at a flag. Buckley, regardless of whether he wishes to coach on, should be encouraged to coach for the future.
To date, they’ve promoted only Henry into the 22 from that draft haul and the Geelong kid struggled in round one before being dumped. He was marked far harder than senior teammates.
In fairness to the Pies, there’s some extenuating circumstances surrounding some of those draftees and Trent Bianco, a second-year player who might have been called up if not for injury.
McInnes, a prospective midfielder, has just overcome a long-term finger injury and played a VFL practice match on the weekend. Macrae, a natural inside midfielder, was set back by the death of his father, but performed well in the twos on Saturday, as did Poulter.
Recruiters believe that the players drafted from Victoria may not fare as well as usual v non-Victorians due to the shutdown of the NAB League last year. But that should not apply to Poulter or McCreery, as South Australians.
The Magpies have three areas of positional shortfall: key forward, small forward and long-term midfield.
They will not fill each of these holes in one post-season. But, with Nick Daicos – a potential top-three pick – joining them next year, and the crop of 2020 harvested, the timing is right for the oft-conservative Buckley to follow Longmire and Ben Rutten by erring on the side of the young and untried, rather than the tried and tired.
Jake Niall is a Walkley award-winning sports journalist and chief AFL writer for The Age.