Marcus Veerman, chief executive of the social enterprise nudelkart.com and a specialist in helping communities build their own playgrounds, said Moreland Council was too hasty in removing the Coburg North treehouse.
“Just to pull it down without any warning or consultation, I think, is a bit of a shame because it sounds like it was a loved asset in the community and possibly could have been made safe,” he said.
Mr Veerman said council playgrounds often reduced risk to a point where they were unattractive to children, who seek other activities. Not taking risks could harm children’s abilities to deal with challenges.
He said Moreland Council had worked with locals in the past. Last year, after children built a small bicycle jump in Jones Park, Brunswick East, the council accepted it on the condition that jumps were less than a metre high and confined to a set area.
“It is possible to work with community members to create safe and exciting spaces,” he said. “They don’t have to be automatically shut down.”
Barb Champion, executive director of Play Australia, said the demise of the Coburg North treehouse was “very sad for the kids”.
“It is offensive that council ignores the ingenuity of their own residents,” she said. “Public open space is for everyone and therefore should be for the benefit of the community, which includes kids.
“It’s interesting that there is no evidence of injury in ‘risky’ play environments. The reason is that kids learn to manage themselves, which is why Play Australia strongly supports play environments like this one.”
David, whose seven-year-old daughter loved playing in the Coburg North treehouse, said its removal was “utterly ridiculous”.
He said parents including tradesmen had taken care on the build, using quality materials.
David said the council stuck to the rules but was “taking away a bit of fun for the kids. Why do kids have to be in a designated area in a park? Can’t they experience the good old outdoors in the bush?”
Coburg North resident James*, 36, father of Billy*, seven, said he was “really sad and disappointed” at the treehouse removal. “There was a sense of adventure play as opposed to prescribed play.”
But Jason Chambers, general manager of Kidsafe Victoria, said councils had a duty of care to ensure public parks were safe. He said councils should pre-approve the installation of structures to guard against hazards such as lack of guard or handrails, lack of soft flooring and excessive height.
Mr Chambers said councils followed Australian standards of design, construction and maintenance that could prevent children suffering serious injuries.
*Not their real names.
The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up here.