In NSW, a Taiwanese abattoir worker was last year ordered to return to work while he was still bleeding from the mouth from an injury so severe he would later need surgery. The worker was not paid sick leave.
At the Teys abattoir in Biloela where Wang worked, a Sri Lankan man also sustained water and chemical burns and, according to Wang, was also forced to return to work against medical advice. Months later he quit because of the pain, Wang said.
Like hundreds of his countrymen, Wang was brought to Australia by a recruitment syndicate that enticed him with the promise of permanent residency. It would take three years to qualify, he was told. He was so confident he brought his wife with him.
Now officials from the Home Affairs Department are grilling hundreds of mostly Chinese abattoir workers about claims made in their visa applications amid fears some recruitment syndicates have been falsifying work experience and English language tests to meet Australia’s requirements for skilled migrants.
The scrutiny of the meatworkers and recruitment syndicates coincides with a promise by the Morrison government to introduce a new low-skill migrant agricultural worker visa, including for workers in abattoirs, to help deal with what primary producers say is a dire labour shortage.
Privately, migrant abattoir workers from Victoria, NSW and Queensland, most of them Chinese, talk about how they borrowed money or sold possessions to pay recruitment syndicates $70,000 or more to secure a job in Australia after being promised it would lead to permanent residency.
According to Wang, many lie to get their visas because very few people in China with high levels of English would also have worked for three years as a boner or slaughterman – a requirement for a skilled visa.
When those lies are uncovered, individual workers fear they will be punished and forced back to China – a fear that makes them reluctant to speak out, take sick days or demand other rights.
“It is easier for the Australian government to say no to some workers’ visas than to do something against the company owners or the [recruitment] agents. They are big. We are small,” said one Chinese worker from a regional NSW abattoir.
The Victorian secretary of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, Paul Conway, said it was time the public considered the working conditions of the migrant workers who ensured their supermarket shelves were stocked with meat. There were “elements of the meat processing industry that have become reliant on what really is modern-day slavery and exploitation,” he said.
“There’s a massive power imbalance at play. You’ve got the companies, you’ve got the government, you’ve got the recruiters or labour hire, and you’ve got the migrant worker.“
When Wang was scalded in April 2019, he went to the emergency department at a nearby hospital for a few hours before being discharged. The doctor had told him he would need a few weeks off, but the abattoir called Wang in the following day and told him he could perform tasks in the office. Within days he was back in hospital in fear of infection as his burnt skin peeled away.
Once again, he was told he needed to rest, but soon a car arrived at his house to take him to work.
Wang said a senior manager told him he was not to see a doctor without a company representative. With his 457 visa nearing expiration and hopes high for permanent residency sponsorship, Wang felt powerless to object.
“Most people come to Australia for better life and long-time stay visa. I had no choice … I listen to him [his boss]. I come to factory every day and keep silent,” he said.
Months later Wang secretly went to see another doctor for knee pain. He paid for an MRI scan because migrant visa workers are not eligible for Medicare. Somehow, Wang says, Teys management found out.
“Within one week they fire me. The reason is I had a bad attitude.”
Wang enlisted law firm Maurice Blackburn and sued Teys Australia for unfair dismissal. The case was settled on a confidential basis. His recruitment agent was unable to find him a job elsewhere.
Teys executive chairman Brad Teys questioned Wang’s account, saying he was medically cleared to come back to work. “He got the shits and walked off the job twice. We let him go the second time,” he said.
Veteran Labor senator Kim Carr questioned the claims by many meat processors about being forced to rely on migrant workers because Australian-born people refuse to work in abattoirs.
“This is a question of proper wages and conditions,” Senator Carr said, highlighting abattoirs in Geelong and Warrigal that did not rely on foreign workers. “It’s the Chinese now but in the past it has been other ethnic groups. The common denominator here is exploitation.”
Senator Carr said recent concerns about visa fraud in the meat processing industry should not come as a surprise considering various parliamentary committees and government inquiries had found systemic structural problems.
In 2019 the federal government’s Migrant Worker Taskforce, led by former Australian Competition and Consumer Commission chiefs Alan Fels and David Cousins, called for the establishment of a national labour hire registration scheme. Two years later, no such scheme exists.
Back in China, Wang is looking for work. He has got fresh tattoos to cover his scarred skin.
The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up here.